Streaming service review: Apple TV+

Apple TV+ main page

Last updated on July 23rd, 2023

Apple TV+ is Apple’s streaming service entry in the “streaming wars.” Launched on November 1, 2019,  Apple TV+ (named after the Apple TV app and streaming devices) takes a cue from HBO and places a big emphasis on original series over an extensive back catalog. (Given Apple is sitting on $324 billion in assets, it can certainly afford to do so.) The streaming service has also gained some critical praise for its originals, including “Ted Lasso.” Apple TV+ is also now the exclusive digital home for the major “Peanuts” specials.

Apple’s streaming service has also been the subject of a few parodies in its short lifespan. YouTube’s “How It Should Have Ended” series pokes fun at Apple’s service (and other streaming services like Disney+) with Aquaman showing up (at the 2:43 mark) to excitedly proclaim “don’t forget ‘See!’ Apple TV+, *woo!*” (Jason Momoa, who plays the Sea King in the movies, has a starring role in the Apple TV+ fantasy drama “See.”)

Still, how well does Apple TV+ stack up against other services? Below is my Apple TV+ review, and whether it’s worth subscribing.

Pros of Apple TV+

Ted Lasso section on Apple TV+
“Ted Lasso” section highlight on Apple TV+. (Apple / screenshot by author)

It’s inexpensive

Apple TV+ costs $5/month after a free seven-day trial. That’s on par with services like Paramount+, Discovery+, and Boomerang.

At first, Apple also offered one-year-long free trials for anyone that buys an Apple device. (That’s how I got Apple TV+, thanks to buying a new iPhone early this year.) However, Apple’s since dialed the offer back to a free three months.

Apple TV+ is also bundled with their omnibus “Apple One” subscription service, which comes with Apple Music, Arcade, iCloud+, and more starting at $15/month.

Lots of original shows

Apple’s put most of its emphasis on original programming for the service. One advantage of such is not needing to worry about dealing with studio rights to programming. Apple also doesn’t have to worry about said material being yanked to go to a rival’s own streaming service, as is happening with Netflix. Finally, owning shows outright makes an international launch much easier; Apple TV+ is currently available in over 100 countries.

Fortunately, some of their original shows are receiving critical praise. The biggest hit on Apple TV+ to date is “Ted Lasso,” a comedy about a cheerful American football coach hired to coach a British soccer team. It’s won several Emmys, including for Outstanding Comedy.

Apple also bought the rights to the “Fraggle Rock” catalog, with plans to produce a new series based on the classic Jim Henson characters.

There’s also the most bizarre sounding original production planned: a reboot of the 1981 time-travel comedy/adventure film “Time Bandits.” That’s the last thing I ever expected to get a reboot or remake (or even thought about) in 2021.

Animation-wise, Apple TV+ offers a few adult-oriented cartoons, such as “Central Park.” There’s also a new “Harriet the Spy” series, based on the classic children’s books. (It also has a catchy theme song.) The most prominent animated offering, however, is the “Peanuts” animated specials library, which Apple bought the exclusive rights.

No commercials

One big selling point of Apple TV+: there’s no commercials. For most services at its $5/month price point, it’s usually for an ad-supported tier, with an ad-free tier costing more.

Other streaming services available through Apple TV+

Similar to Amazon Prime Video, Apple TV+’s app also lets you subscribe to other streaming services, using Apple’s app as a central hub.

Among the services available: Paramount+, Showtime, Starz, AMC+, Acorn TV, BET+, Cinemax, Noggin, and Shudder. Earlier this year, Apple offered a discounted bundle of Paramount+ and Showtime via Apple TV+, but doesn’t seem to be offering such now.

Cons of Apple TV+

All of Apple TV+'s dramas
All of Apple TV+’s dramas. (Apple / screenshot by author)

A poor back catalog

The biggest downside of Apple TV+ is its minimal back catalog. This stems from Apple’s initial plan of offering all-original content. The pandemic and subscriber numbers made Apple realize that they need to offer more of a back catalog for customers to justify Apple TV+ as a recurring monthly expense. As such, they’ve been trying to expand said catalog.

That said, progress on that front is slow so far; as a result, Apple TV+ has the smallest catalog among the major streaming services. (The “Fraggle Rock” purchase above is still one of its bigger back catalog additions to date.) Given at a similar price point, one can get a ton of programming from Paramount+, Peacock, or Hulu (albeit at the ad-based tiers), this is an area where Apple TV+ needs major improvement.

User interface needs improvement

Apple TV+ is also similar to Amazon Prime Video for one of the wrong reasons. Like Prime Video, the user interface for Apple TV+ mixes Apple TV+ content with Apple’s TV shows and movies for rent or sale (like the now-Windows-only iTunes app). Confusing things further, the TV+ app also lists the TV shows and movies available through the non-TV+ streaming services available through the app. The Apple TV+ content features the service’s logo in the bottom right corner; TV shows and movies available to rent/purchase have no logo at all. Non-TV+ streaming service material is less clearly identified as such. Most such programs have their parent service’s logo displayed, while others have no logo at all. “Star Trek: Discovery” is a case of the latter; clicking on it shows you’re supposed to watch the show within Paramount+, save for one free episode available.

The TV+ app has separate tabs at the top for TV+ (TV+-only material), movies (from all sources), TV shows (again from all sources), and library (for user-purchased content).

This is one major flaw of Apple TV+. The app should make a clearer distinction between material available on the service and material you’ll have to pay to rent/buy (or get via another streaming service) separately.

The exclusive digital home of “Peanuts” (and they mean it)

I’ve written before about Apple buying the exclusive “Peanuts” rights. But to summarize: Apple gets to make new “Peanuts” material for Apple TV+, as well as exclusively stream the classic holiday specials (“It’s the Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown,” “A Charlie Brown Christmas,” etc.).

This exclusivity applies to the major “Peanuts” specials in any digital format. You can no longer buy a digital copy of the major “Peanuts” specials. And if you’re using PBS’ free streaming service to watch your local affiliate, a screen like the following pops up on PBS’ airing of the specials:

Peanuts specials unavailable on PBS streaming screen
PBS streaming screen stating “Peanuts” specials are unavailable. (PBS / screenshot by author)

As I note below, your best bet’s to buy the “Peanuts” specials on Blu-ray instead.

Other observations

It's the Small Things Charlie Brown
“It’s the Small Things Charlie Brown.” (Apple TV+)

Apple TV+ does an excellent job at offering closed captioning in multiple languages. Besides the expected languages for a North American streaming service (English, French, Spanish, and Portuguese), other languages I saw offered include (among others): Arabic, Chinese, Czech, Danish, Dutch, Estonian, Finnish, Indonesian, Hungarian, Hebrew, Korean, Latvian, Lithuanian, Brazilian and Portugal Portuguese, Tamil, Telugu, Thai, and Vietnamese. Also offered for subtitles are France and Quebec versions of French, and Latin America and Spain versions of Spanish.

This is a thoughtful aspect of Apple TV+, and might make it an easier sell in other countries.

Another thoughtful aspect is including age ranges for children’s content, using Common Sense Media scores. Rotten Tomatoes ratings are also included on (non-TV+) movies.

Who should use Apple TV+?

Harriet the Spy on Apple TV+
“Harriet the Spy” on Apple TV+. Note “Elf” isn’t a part of Apple TV+, but a film I already own. (Apple / screenshot by author)

To summarize my Apple TV+ review, the streaming service is best for the following users:

  • Those that get Apple TV+ for free (such as a trial).
  • Fans of “Ted Lasso” and/or one of the other shows.
  • “Peanuts” fans who don’t have a DVD/Blu-ray player (or don’t want physical media).
  • Those looking for an inexpensive secondary streaming service without ads.

Other than the above categories, there’s not a strong argument in favor of Apple TV+ as an ongoing subscription. Animation fans definitely shouldn’t make this their main service, as there’s not much available here. On the expensive end, HBO Max and Netflix offer a similar experience to Apple TV+ (strong original programming, no ads), but much bigger libraries. On the cheaper end, Apple TV+ is up against Hulu, Disney+, and Paramount+, all which also have much larger libraries.

That said, if you’re just interested in “Ted Lasso” or some other show, you could just binge Apple TV+ after a season’s completed and then cancel.

“Peanuts” fans: skip Apple TV+ and buy the Blu-rays instead

For “Peanuts” fans that don’t care about anything else on Apple TV+, I advise buying Blu-rays of your favorite specials instead of paying for an ongoing subscription to Apple TV+. You’ll own the “Peanuts” specials outright, won’t have to deal with DRM or attempts at artificial digital scarcity, and won’t have to worry about remembering to cancel Apple TV+ after the holidays are over.

The best options as of this writing:

  • For the Halloween, Thanksgiving, and Christmas specials (the most famous ones), get the “Peanuts Holiday Collection.” It has all three specials, plus a few minor ones as extras.
  • Otherwise, “It’s the Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown,” “A Charlie Brown Thanksgiving,” and “A Charlie Brown Christmas” are all available on individual Blu-ray releases. Any big-box store or Amazon will usually have these for sale, especially around their respective holidays.

Screenshot of Apple TV+’s main page. (Apple / screenshot by author)

Anthony Dean

Anthony Dean is the owner of Diverse Tech Geek and Diverse Media Notes.

View all posts by Anthony Dean →

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *