Could DC and Marvel use some content diversity? (The answer’s “yes.”)

  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  

Last week on Twitter, there was a discussion on how reliant DC and Marvel, the “Big Two” of American comics, are on their various properties. Based on the discussion, I thought I’d look over DC and Marvel’s various franchises myself, to see if “Wolverine Publicity” (as TV Tropes might put it) really holds true.

DC

Going by DC’s November 2013 solicitations, my goal was to find “New 52” ongoing books that aren’t related to Superman, Batman, the Justice League, or Green Lantern. And here’s the results… the sole ongoing DC books consist of:

  • Animal Man
  • The Green Team
  • The Movement
  • Stormwatch
  • Swamp Thing

That’s all, if you’re looking for mainstream DCU material not tied in any way to Superman, Batman, Green Lantern, or the JLA.

Meanwhile, the Batman books, including ongoing books using characters or settings related to Batman (including villains, sidekicks, etc.), are truly lopsided: a whopping 22 out of 52 DCU-set titles, or 42% of DC’s output! The Bat-books include: Batman; Batgirl; Batwing; Birds of Prey; Catwoman; Nightwing; Detective Comics; Red Hood and the Outlaws; Justice League; Justice League of America; Suicide Squad; Teen Titans; Katana; World’s Finest; Earth-2; Batman/Superman; Harley Quinn; Batman and Robin; Batman: The Dark Knight Returns; Batwoman; Talon; and All-Star Western.

It’s pretty obvious that DC and parent conglomerate Time-Warner rely on Batman a tad too much… which seems to be impacting their media side of things: Batman inserted into the “Man of Steel” sequel, the endless stream of Batman TV cartoons, etc. This lack of variety also doesn’t help DC/Time-Warner in their goal of matching or one-upping Marvel/Disney’s variety of superhero movies. Nor does it make the “New 52” a very diverse place, especially if one’s not a huge Batman fan.

Assuming $4 an issue, it’d cost $88 a month to follow the entirety of the Dark Knight and his massive entourage of friends, sidekicks, enemies, and even settings (“All-Star Western” takes place in 19th Century Gotham City).

Marvel

Similar to DC above, and using the November 2013 solicitations as a guide, I attempted to find a mainstream Marvel Universe-set book that isn’t currently tied into the Avengers, X-Men, or Spider-Man franchises. Unfortunately, in recent years, Marvel’s gone rather overboard in having made most of its high-profile characters Avengers at some point, and/or using mutant powers as an origin source (thus often tying them to the X-Men books). Thanks to this and other tie-ins, the only Marvel book I could find that meets this criteria is “Nova.” (At least, until Marvel inevitably decides the young hero should join the Avengers or X-Men…)

However, in Marvel’s favor, the Marvel Universe comics aren’t dominated by one franchise to the degree that Batman dominates DC. The Avengers, X-books (even with Wolverine Publicity in force), and Spidey all seem to split up the Marvel Universe pretty evenly. There’s also some books that, while technically still tied to these three, usually stand on their own outside of the forced tie-ins: Fantastic Four, Guardians of the Galaxy, Captain Marvel, Deadpool, etc.

Overall, while Marvel could use some diversity of its own, it seems in a better position than DC these days.


  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *